
Data Debate

PENNSYLVANIA STATE POLICE ARE SUING TO BLOCK THE RELEASE OF DATA that would shed light on the agency’s communications with federal immigration officials during President Donald Trump’s second term.
A win would not only shield the data, but set a precedent that weakens the public’s ability to use Pennsylvania’s Right-to-Know Law to access government officials’ emails. The case is currently before Commonwealth Court, and could get appealed up to the state Supreme Court.Â
It stems from a Pittsburgh man’s July request seeking metadata for emails sent between domains operated by State Police officials and ICE or the Department of Homeland Security. Pennsylvania’s Office of Open Records sided with the requestor, but State Police are now arguing the office erred, and the request is “overly broad” and requires too extensive of a records search.
Metadata essentially describes other data within computer files. In the context of emails, metadata refers to subject lines, senders, recipients, and dates and times emails are sent — just not the body text of messages.



